Tallahassee homeowners and business owners often face a critical decision when planning a new roof: go with a metal roof or stick with traditional shingles?
With Florida’s intense heat, tropical rain, and strict building codes, selecting the right roofing materials isn’t just about appearance—it’s about ensuring your home stays protected, remains energy efficient, and delivers long-term value.
Here are seven key insights to help you make an informed choice in Tallahassee.
Key Takeaways
- Steel roofing and aluminum panels offer exceptional durability and reflect heat, which can cut cooling costs.
- Asphalt shingles are a reliable, lower-cost alternative with strong performance under proper maintenance.
- Tallahassee’s hot, wet climate increases the risk of mold and accelerates material wear, which should impact your material selection.
- Choosing between shingles and other roofing materials depends on your project goals, budget, and curb appeal preferences.
- Tadlock Roofing offers both residential and commercial solutions backed by experienced contractors and industry certifications.
1. Performance Under Tallahassee’s Intense Heat
Tallahassee experiences high summer temperatures and UV exposure.
Metal roofing systems, particularly those made from aluminum or steel, reflect sunlight and minimize heat absorption, resulting in better energy efficiency and significantly reduced cooling costs for your home or business.
Shingle roofing systems, while widely used, tend to absorb more solar heat, which may drive up energy bills and stress your HVAC system, especially in Florida’s peak summer months.
2. Mold, Moisture, and Rain Resistance
Heavy rain and humidity are part of life in Tallahassee, and these conditions contribute to mold, algae, and moisture buildup on roofing surfaces. A metal roof offers a smooth, non-porous surface, making it more resistant to these issues.
Unlike shingles, which may trap moisture or degrade over time, metal panels with integrated trim provide more complete protection. This is a major advantage for homeowners seeking long-lasting solutions to Florida’s wet climate.
3. Lifespan and Long-Term Investment
A metal roof can last 40 to 70 years, making it a sound investment for those prioritizing longevity. Asphalt shingles typically have a life expectancy of 15 to 30 years. Though shingles offer a lower upfront cost, they may require more frequent replacement and maintenance.
For homeowners in Tallahassee looking for a durable, low-maintenance system, metal roofing consistently outperforms over time.
4. Storm Durability and Wind Resistance
Strong winds and tropical storms challenge every roof in Tallahassee.
Metal roofing—particularly steel roofing with interlocking panels—can withstand wind speeds up to 140 mph when properly installed. High-performance shingles also offer impact resistance but are more vulnerable to edge lifting and water intrusion.
Choosing the right roofing material helps keep your home protected and covered, especially during storm season.
5. Installation Time and Contractor Expertise
Shingle roofing tends to be quicker and easier to install, reducing labor hours on your job. However, metal roof installation requires specialized skills and attention to detail. At Tadlock Roofing, our trained crew manages both systems with precision and professionalism.
For every roof installation, we evaluate each project based on your structure, needs, and market expectations, ensuring a complete installation that meets Florida code.
6. Curb Appeal and Architectural Style
Whether you prefer the classic charm of architectural shingles or the sleek, modern aesthetic of standing seam metal, both systems contribute to your home’s curb appeal.
Metal roofing is increasingly favored in new construction for its contemporary finishes and custom color options, which can elevate the look of any residential or commercial property.
Meanwhile, shingles offer versatility and a traditional feel that blends well in older neighborhoods across Tallahassee.
7. Maintenance, Warranties, and Peace of Mind
Metal roofs are ideal for Florida’s climate due to their low maintenance needs and resistance to corrosion, pests, and UV damage. Most metal roofing systems come with warranties up to 50 years, while shingles may require closer upkeep and carry shorter warranty terms.
With Tadlock Roofing’s Roof Preventative Maintenance (RPM) Program, customers gain scheduled inspections, prompt repairs, and trusted service that extends the life of your roof while keeping your home or business secure year-round.
Ready to Explore Metal or Shingle Roofing Options in Tallahassee?
At Tadlock Roofing, we bring over 40 years of experience helping homeowners and business owners across Tallahassee, FL, make confident roofing decisions.
Whether you’re upgrading your roof due to storm damage, exploring energy-efficient options, or planning a new construction project, our expert contractors are here to help.
Our team is committed to protecting your home, delivering high-quality craftsmanship, and providing local service you can trust.
Contact us at (855) 964-7663 for a free estimate.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can metal roofs be installed over existing shingles in Tallahassee?
Yes, in many cases, metal roofing can be installed over a single layer of shingles, reducing labor and debris. Local codes and roof structure must be evaluated first by qualified contractors.
Are metal roofs noisy during Florida thunderstorms?
When properly installed with solid decking and insulation, metal roofs are no louder than shingles during heavy rain or storms. Most homeowners notice no difference in sound levels indoors.
Do metal roofs attract lightning in Florida’s stormy climate?
Metal roofs do not increase the likelihood of a lightning strike. In fact, they are noncombustible and safely disperse energy, making them one of the safest materials during thunderstorms.
How do metal roofs impact home insurance in Florida?
Some Florida insurers offer reduced premiums for metal roofs due to their fire resistance and wind durability. Check with your provider, as discounts vary by carrier and roof system.
